I will support the advise that Chris and Ed have already given. The cases look acceptable to me. I wouldn't be overly concerned with them at this point. I do think a little more crimp will be in order and pay a little more attention to COL. It isn't uncommon to have to "tweak" a new load.
Don't retreat! Reload!!!
Just to come in here to say you have been getting some great advice. God I love this forum in the way that so many want to help with problems. After looking at the second set of pics I do agree on needing more crimp. I shoot Raniers all the time and they are always right on with the sizing, I have never experienced a problem. Yes you do have a way to progress with that particular formula you are using. I can offer you this small piece of information, the crimp on Raniers will be easier to notice than it is on FMJ projectiles. My advice would be proceed with the crimp slowly until you see that the Ranier bullet is deforming SLIGHTLY and stop there. That should give you a good crimp and better performance as well. Be SAFE.....Shoot WELL
The term "Undocumented Alien" is like calling a drug pusher an "Un-Licensed Pharmacist"
I love this forum too, everyone is so helpful....
I increased the crimp and this is the mark that was left on the bullet head.....
(sorry looks black as copper tarnishes super fast here in Hawaii)
is that too little or too much?
Last edited by Dolomite; 07-10-2013 at 05:43 PM.
It's good to be cautious, but unfortunately we cannot give you our "experience' or our "feel" for things as subjective as crimp. Here's a "visual" to try to help... In my opinion, the photo shows from not enough to too much, but I've shot rounds "like" all of these with no problem as long as the charge was correct.
Last edited by EdF702; 07-10-2013 at 06:12 PM.
------)_'_\ * (
"----------\ * \
gen3 G34, gen3 G19, gen4 G17, gen4 G21, gen4 G19, gen3 G17L
Browning Hi Power 9mm Belgium
Ruger GP 100 3" .357 magnum
Smith & Wesson Model 10-5 .38 spec (2)
Smith & Wesson Model 17-4 .22 LR
Smith & Wesson Model 29-2, 29-3
Smith & Wesson Model 624, 25-8, 28-2, 19-4
Sig P226 "KD", P220 ST
Beretta 92 Italian
Winchester Super X model 1
"indecision may, or may not, be my problem!"
thanks Ed for the pics... I'll give it try and see what happens.....
Nice work Ed! Great pics!
Great job on the photo, Ed...
"While the anti-gunners seem very concerned about the "one life" that your firearm might take -- they are not very concerned about the lives it will save." Jon H. Gutmacher, Florida Firearms - Law, Use & Ownership